Richard Donkin .com
 
 
   
Fishing books
 

November 2007 – Three new fishing books

Anyone looking for something special in fishing books as a Christmas present is spoilt for choice this year. The autumn has delivered three excellent books that are more than mere decoration for the coffee table.

A couple of years ago I bid successfully at a charity for an artwork commission from David Miller, who specialises in painting fish, often drawn from studies and photographs he has taken while diving in rivers.

He gave me regular updates on his book, Beneath The Surface*, as we chatted on the progress of the painting. Like many artists, Miller likes to get the details right and that’s clear enough in this stunning collection of paintings, sketches and photographs of fish, faithfully depicted in their habitat.

Miller writes that every dive he makes is like a journey back in to his childhood imagination that has never deserted him when fishing. I think many of us could relate to that. How often, when casting a line, do you picture the underwater scene? Diving with fish, he says “the reality is much as I expected only infinitely better.”

The real difference in swimming among fish, he says, is experiencing the play of light in the water and it is this that makes his paintings so outstanding. The one I have on my wall at home has beams of light permeating a chalk stream, illuminating a trout holding station by the side of a clump of rununculous.

The book is arranged in three sections covering coarse, game and sea fish. Much as I love all of his work, it is the paintings of pike that stand out for me and I am not surprised to read him confessing that “left to indulge myself I could probably paint pike for ever.”

The pike held a similar fascination for Fred Buller, who some years ago wrote what must be the definitive work on big pike. Now he has done the same for the Atlantic Salmon.

His new book, The Domesday Book of Giant Salmon**, was forty years in the making as the author painstakingly documented every record he could find of big Atlantic salmon. Where no pictures existed, Buller went out of his way to find and photograph casts of big fish.

A few weeks ago, around the publication date of the book, there were reports of a giant fish on the River Ness in Scotland. The first accounts suggested something of record breaking size although these were later toned down. The fish could not be weighed before it was released but subsequent reports and photographs publish in Trout and Salmon Magazine suggest it could have been something between 40 and 50lb.

A remarkable fish, for sure, but it wouldn’t have made the list in this book which includes stories of fish around the 100 lb mark although no fish approaching this size has been verified on rod and line.

Buller has included net caught salmon but his “number one list” comprises fly caught fish. “I believe that to catch a salmon weighing over 50 lb on fly is the highest distinction that a salmon fisherman can hope to achieve in his or her lifetime,” he writes.

At the top of his fly-caught list is a fish, reputed to have weighed 72 lb, caught on the river Tay in Scotland during the early 1800s by someone known only as “a member of the Athole family,” almost certainly an ancestor of the existing Duke of Atholl. The fish was said to have been hooked in the Fernyhaugh pool about three miles above Dunkeld. Buller believes that someone somewhere may have a detailed account that could lend provenance to the claim.

My third choice for your library is an excellent collection of salmon river photographs with accompanying descriptions in A Celebration of Salmon Rivers***, produced to raise money for the North Atlantic Salmon Fund. I met the photographer, Randy Ashton, while he was on assignment in Iceland last year, so knew to expect some great images after viewing his work at the time.

What an assignment, to spend the summers of 2005 and 2006 travelling across the whole range of the Atlantic salmon, helped and accommodated along the way by friends and supporters of the fund, founded in 1989 by Icelandic businessman and fisherman, Orri Vigfusson.

What struck me most about the book was the variety of Atlantic Salmon rivers, from relatively modest streams such as the Dart and the Exe to the broad waters of the Yokanga and Ponoi on the Kola Peninsula.

These are three exceptional books and I’m loath to recommend any over the rest. If I had to pick one it would be the Buller book, a must for any salmon fisher. But you could say the same for the collection of salmon rivers and in buying that you would know that the profits would be helping salmon conservation.

David Miller’s book is special for me since it compliments the painting I have on my wall. There’s only one way to overcome the problem and that would be to ask Father Christmas for all three of them. It’s greedy I know, but you need something to feed the anticipation for the season ahead.

*Beneath The Surface, by David Miller is published by the Langford Press, price £38.

**The Domesday Book of Giant Salmon, A Record of the Largest Atlantic Salmon Ever Caught, by Fred Buller, is published by Constable, price £50.

***A celebration of Salmon Rivers, is published by Merlin Unwin Books, price £35.

See also: October 2006 – Iceland: a fish fit for a king

David Miller Art: http://www.davidmillerart.co.uk/index.htm

   
©2006 Richard Donkin - all rights reserved